Welsh Rarebit (Classic Cheese on Toast Recipe)
Welsh rarebit is a type of open-faced grilled cheese sandwich with so much flavor, and it comes together in minutes for a quick lunch anytime.
Have you ever heard of Welsh rarebit? I remember eating it as a little girl growing up in Scotland, and loving it, but I don’t think it’s a very well-known dish in the US.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
So allow me to introduce you to this delicious dish you can easily prepare for a quick lunch, dinner or even a snack.
What is Welsh Rarebit?
Welsh rarebit is simply a lightly toasted piece of bread with a melted cheese concoction poured on top and then broiled/grilled until golden brown. As the name denotes, it was created in Wales and is known as a “poor man’s dish” rather like Italian cucina povera. It usually contains a type of melty cheese, like Cheddar, a liquid and few other ingredients to flavor the mixture. Years ago, I shared my recipe for Irish rarebit which includes bits of cornichons.
![Irish rarebit overhead shot with clover Irish rarebit overhead shot with clover](https://www.christinascucina.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/1BF96A42-44BC-4E58-A790-02CA93D9E7D1_1_201_a-600x400.jpeg)
How do you Pronounce Rarebit?
There are now two ways to pronounce the word “rarebit”. I grew up saying “rabbit”, but now I have read (and heard) that pronouncing it as it is written, as in “rare-bit” is acceptable. I heard it pronounced this way recently by Ryan Reynolds (who happens to co-own a Welsh football team).
Why was he talking about Welsh rarebit? Because Wrexham AFC has published its own official cookbook! I thought I was prolific with two rarebit recipes, but clearly I’m a loser because this cookbook is called 20 Ways to Make Rarebit by Ryan Reynolds and Rob McElhenney.
Hopefully these two jokers don’t put out a recipe book for Welsh cakes next!
Note: read carefully before purchasing the rarebit cookbook because every recipe is exactly the same except for the garnish 🤣 However, it’s all for good as all proceeds go to Wrexham Foodbank.
While Welsh rarebit is basically a glorified cheese on toast, it’s a great option for St. David’s Day (March 1st) and obviously anytime you want a quick and unique cheesy meal! Make it authentically Welsh by using a Welsh cheese. Once you make it a few times, you can tweak it to your liking and you won’t even need to refer to a recipe–it’s that easy!
Can I make Welsh Rarebit without Guinness or Beer?
Of course, you can omit the Guinness or beer and use water, milk or even hard cider when making Welsh rarebit.
Note: you can use any type of savory bread you choose. I used a country loaf from Tartine.
Welsh Rarebit Recipe
adapted from Great British Cookery cookbook by Lucy Knox, et al. Serves 1 (or 2 smaller portions)
FULL PRINTABLE RECIPE BELOW
Ingredients
- strong/mature Cheddar cheese or another similar cheese
- butter
- Worcestershire sauce
- English mustard
- flour
- white pepper
- Guinness (or another stout or ale)
- bread
Toast the bread on one side only (use a broiler/grill if your toaster doesn’t have this function).
Put all of the ingredients, except for the toast and Guinness, into a pan, with the butter at the bottom, and place over a low heat.
Add the Guinness, then stir to combine the ingredients. Don’t worry if you think it’s too dry, the cheese mixture won’t be very wet.
Preheat the broiler/grill at this time.
![melted cheese mixture melted cheese mixture](https://www.christinascucina.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/954DD592-8102-4EB4-A2DA-5A3642B6498A_1_201_a-600x729.jpeg)
Continue to stir the cheese mixture until a smooth paste forms, then pour over the untoasted side of the slices of bread. It turns into a rather fun consistency!
Place on a baking tray and put under a preheated broiler/grill for a minute or so or until golden brown.
Serve immediately.
If you love cheese check out all my other cheese-y recipes!
Don’t miss another recipe, sign up for my free subscription (only 1 email a week after my intro email)!
Love melty cheese? Don’t live one more day without discovering Swiss raclette! It’s such a dreamy cheese, honest!
![Welsh rarebit on a plate](https://www.christinascucina.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/02/B5C16EDB-DAF5-448C-90A6-5EE03B85E438_1_201_a.jpeg)
Welsh Rarebit (Classic Cheese on Toast)
Special Equipment
- 1 toaster
- 1 baking tray
Ingredients
- 4 oz Cheddar cheese (strong/mature)
- 2 tsp butter
- 1 tsp Worcestershire sauce
- 1 tsp English mustard or French or a mild German
- 1 tsp flour
- 3 Tbsp Guinness
- 2 slices bread
Instructions
- Toast the bread on one side only (use a broiler/grill if your toaster doesn't have this function).
- Put all of the ingredients, except for the toast and Guinness, into a pan, with the butter at the bottom, and place over a low heat.
- Add the Guinness, then stir to combine the ingredients. Don't worry if you think it's too dry, the cheese mixture won't be very wet.
- Preheat the broiler/grill at this time.
- Continue to stir the cheese mixture until a smooth paste forms, then pour over the untoasted side of the slices of bread.
- Place on a baking tray and put under a preheated broiler/grill for a minute or so or until golden brown. Serve immediately.
Notes
- This can serve 2 smaller appetites.
Nutrition
Christina’s Cucina is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associate Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.
My parents pronounced it rabbit too as we were growing up, causing us to absolutely refuse to eat it because we thought it had rabbit in it 😂, right up until I saw how it was spelled and read the recipe!
I suspect it was deliberate on Dad’s part though…
My kids have since seen an old Gomer Pyle re-run where Gomer has Welsh Rarebit, and deals with the side effects of disturbed sleep: I might just have to make this one for them!
That’s hilarious! Yes, I think your kids would love it after seeing it on Gomer Pyle!
It’s a grilled cheese! Every time I see this name I have to rediscover what the heck it is. Such a strange name!!! It looks good.
Haha! Yes, it is! :)
Is the mustard a spicy mustard or plain yellow?
Hi Margaret, I wouldn’t use the plain yellow. English, French or even a mild German mustard will be best. You can also use mustard powder.